Kilma Protocol Main smart contract audit

HashlockCode version: not recorded (see the report)

Hashlock reviewed Kilma Protocol (Kilma Protocol Main smart contract audit) on 1 Dec 2025: 44 findings, 0 critical; 42 marked fixed, 2 acknowledged.

No open critical findings
Open the reportOpen Kilma Protocol’s security record

Report hosted on GitHub.

Trustblock does not review code.

Findings44

Statuses are the security firm’s own, from its report.

SeverityOpenAcknowledgedFixed
Critical000
High006
Medium0022
Low0214
HighCarbonClassVault.sol#_depositCredits, _withdrawCarbonCredits - User controlled couponBurn parameter allows arbitrary coupon burnFixed

The report gives no description here.

HighK2StakingFacet.sol#_allocateK2 - Incorrect beta calculation due to passing total instead of delta in k2 allocationFixed

The report gives no description here.

HighKvcmStakingFacet#_unlockKvcm - Missing allocation cleanup on unlockFixed

The report gives no description here.

HighOperationsFacet#retireCarbonCreditViaAggregator - Excess coupon burn on free retirementFixed

The report gives no description here.

HighRiskyYieldFacet.sol#_getBetaSqForDay - Incorrect default value causes underflow revert in deallocationsFixed

The report gives no description here.

HighRMLPRewardsFacet#claimLPRewards - function is inaccessible to users due to incorrect access controlFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumCarbonClassVault#getAvailableTonnes - Coupons can become unbacked by liquid tonnes after withdrawalsFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumCarbonClassVault#updateCreditConfig - Credit config not synchronized with CarbonLedgerFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumCarbonClassVault#updateMaturityId - Maturity ID 0 not properly handledFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumCarbonLedger#migrateCreditBetweenClasses - Missing approval prevents migration from completingFixed

The report gives no description here.

Show 10 more
MediumCarbonVaultFactory - Vaults deployed with version 0 cannot be upgradedFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumK2StakingFacet, KvcmStakingFacet - Incorrect lambda checkpoint timing when beta changesFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumK2YieldCurveFacet#pullK2YieldFromEscrow - dailyPulled mapping collision after updateSchedule resets start timeFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumK2YieldCurveFacet#updateSchedule - resets cumulative token allocation breaking emission continuityFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumKvcmIncentivesCurveFacet - Partial claimed Kvcm locks remain in global totals, skewing yield curveFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumKvcmIncentivesCurveFacet#_getLockClaimValueAtMidnightIndex - underestimates yield when unprocessed deposits existFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumKvcmIncentivesCurveFacet#_validateLockingInterval - function ignores yieldDistributionInterval and only checks active rangeFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumKvcmLPStakingFacet#stakeLPWithPermit, stakeLPForWithPermit - Permit functions fail due to incorrect msg.sender in token transferFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumKvcmStakingFacet#reallocateKvcm - Incorrect removal of maturity aggregate allocationFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumMaturityManager - Contract inherits Pausable but exposes no pause/unpause functionsFixed

The report gives no description here.

Show 10 more
MediumMaturityManager#updateMaxMaturityId - Timestamp corruption due to uninitialized mappingFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumOperationsMath#_computeExponentialGrowth - rateDelta is computed before timeDelta is capped and rateDelta is never recomputedFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumProtocolMinter#transferK2ToRewardManager - Calls IRewardsEscrow non existent functionFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumProtocolRewardsEscrow#escrowK2Rewards - Missing Integration with ProtocolMinterFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumProtocolRewardsEscrow#transferK2ToTreasury - Incorrect access control modifierFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumRiskyYieldFacet#computeRY - reverts because IntervalData.kVCMYield is never setFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumRiskyYieldUtilsLib#_settleYieldForLP - Underflow when processing index 0 entriesFixed

The report gives no description here.

MediumStakingManagerPauseFacet#onlySystemAdmin - Pause Controls Require Owner and Both RolesFixed

The report gives no description here.

LowCarbonClassVault#matureForwardCarbon - Unbounded Loops Can Hit Gas LimitsFixed

The report gives no description here.

LowCarbonLedger.sol#unregisterCreditForClass - ERC1155 partial unregister locks remaining tokenIdsFixed

The report gives no description here.

Show 10 more
LowCarbonVaultFactory - Unused EnumerableSet Import and Using DirectiveFixed

The report gives no description here.

LowCarbonVaultFactory, ProtocolSupplyOracle - Missing Storage Gaps in Upgradeable ContractsFixed

The report gives no description here.

LowCarbonVaultFactory#updateAccessManager - Authority Update Lacks Contract Type ValidationFixed

The report gives no description here.

LowKvcmLockNFT - Transfer Restrictions Comment Does Not Match ImplementationFixed

The report gives no description here.

LowKvcmLockNFT#initialize - Unused owner_ ParameterFixed

The report gives no description here.

LowMaturityManager#getMaturityTimeframe - Missing maturity ID validationFixed

The report gives no description here.

LowMultiple contracts - Floating pragmaFixed

The report gives no description here.

LowMultiple contracts - State changes without eventsFixed

The report gives no description here.

LowProtocolAccessManager#constructor - Redundant zero address checkFixed

The report gives no description here.

LowRateLimiterLib#updateLiquidSupplyRateLimiter - Comment Does Not Match ConditionFixed

The report gives no description here.

Show 2 more
LowRMKVCMStakersRewardsFacet#burnSharesForKVCMStaker - Inconsistent Pausability on Burn FunctionsFixed

The report gives no description here.

LowRollUpdateFacet#distributeKvcmLockYieldForInterval, K2YieldCurveFacet#pullK2YieldFromEscrow, CarbonLedger#executeMatureForwardCarbon - Missing separate role for automated functionsFixed

The report gives no description here.

Contracts in scope

No deployed address is recorded for this audit.

The report names a repository or files. Open the report to see its scope.

Part of Kilma Protocol’s security record

Kilma Protocol
Audits2 audits by 1 firmLast audit Dec 2025, by Hashlock.
Critical findingsNo open critical findingsAcross 2 reports.
Open Kilma Protocol’s security record

Security firm

Hashlock

198 projects reviewed · 279 reports · latest Jul 2026

See Hashlock’s audits

Something wrong on this page? A missing report, a wrong date, a finding that was fixed since. Tell us and we check it against its source.

Tell us